The Octopus Files
Sign up for Alpha access today

INSLAW, PROMIS and Danny Casolaro: what the records say

In 1982 the Justice Department hired a small Washington software company, INSLAW, to install its case-management software, PROMIS, in U.S. Attorneys' offices. Within months the two sides were in a dispute over who owned an enhanced version of the software. That dispute ran through a bankruptcy court, two congressional investigations, a special counsel and several Justice Department reviews.

In August 1991 a freelance journalist, Danny Casolaro, was found dead in a hotel room in Martinsburg, West Virginia. He had been researching INSLAW and a wider web of alleged intrigue that he called "the Octopus." Local authorities ruled his death a suicide. His family, some members of Congress and many writers have questioned that finding ever since.

This page walks through the primary records in The Octopus Files INSLAW cabinet in date order. Each entry says what a record states or claims, and it cites the record by document and page. Where official bodies reached different conclusions, the page shows each of them rather than choosing between them.

The Octopus Files is not affiliated with Netflix or with the series American Conspiracy: The Octopus Murders.

Timeline of key records

1982: The contract

  • Record: a Justice Department review of the INSLAW allegations (doc e5c44046, p. 1).
  • What it states:
    • In March 1982 the Department awarded INSLAW a $10 million, three-year contract to install PROMIS (the Prosecutor's Management Information System) in U.S. Attorneys' offices.
    • INSLAW developed PROMIS with public funding from the Law Enforcement Assistance Administration.
    • The first major dispute was over whether INSLAW had proprietary rights in an "allegedly enhanced version" of the software.

September 28, 1987: The bankruptcy court rules against the Department

  • Record: a Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations staff study (doc eee05fce, pp. 4–5).
  • What it states: Judge George F. Bason, Jr. of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Columbia found that the Department "took, converted, stole, ... by trickery, fraud, and deceit" software developed by INSLAW.
  • Later events:
    • The House Judiciary Committee report (doc fab664c4, pp. 47–48) describes District Judge Bryant upholding the ruling, and finding that the Department "acted willfully and fraudulently" to obtain the software.
    • The Justice Department's later review (doc e5c44046, p. 2) records that the bankruptcy proceeding "was eventually dismissed for lack of jurisdiction."
    • On appeal the Department argued that INSLAW's claims were based on contract law (doc fab664c4, p. 48).

August 10, 1991: Casolaro is found dead

  • Record: a Martinsburg City Police press release dated August 15, 1991 (doc 62a130c5, pp. 4–5).
  • What it states:
    • Police, rescue personnel and the county medical examiner were called to room 517 of the Sheraton Martinsburg Inn.
    • They found the body of Joseph Daniel Casolaro, 44, of Fairfax, Virginia.
    • The medical examiner determined the death was a suicide, and the body was released to a funeral home.
    • Police located his family on Monday, August 12, and decided further investigation was warranted because of reports about the nature of his work.

January 25, 1992: Police reaffirm suicide

  • Record: the Justice Department review (doc e5c44046, p. 109).
  • What it states: after a second, more intensive investigation, West Virginia authorities announced that Casolaro "indeed had committed suicide" and closed the case.

September 10, 1992: The House Judiciary Committee report

  • Record: The INSLAW Affair (doc fab664c4, pp. 154–155, footnotes 208–210).
  • What it states:
    • The committee did not make Casolaro's death part of its formal investigation.
    • It recorded that Casolaro "had indicated to a number of individuals that the INSLAW affair was part of a much deeper tangle of intrigues that he called the Octopus," including the Iran-Contra arms deals and BCCI.
    • It noted a police sergeant's statement to committee investigators that the death was handled as a suicide and "the scene had not been protected."
    • A footnote quotes Elliot Richardson, a former Attorney General then representing INSLAW, from the New York Times of October 21, 1991: "I believe he was murdered, but even if that is no more than a possibility, it is a possibility with such sinister implications as to demand a serious effort to discover the truth" (p. 155, footnote 210).
    • Later Justice Department records (doc e5c44046, pp. 109–110) summarize the report as recommending an independent counsel to examine six issues, including "the lingering doubts over certain suspicious circumstances surrounding the death of Daniel Casolaro."

March 1993: The Bua special counsel report

  • Record: the Report of Special Counsel Nicholas J. Bua (doc 7f7a3630).
  • What it states: on Casolaro, the report says the death "was fully and fairly investigated" and that the suicide conclusion "was amply supported by the facts" (pp. 253–254).
  • What later records say about it:
    • Attorney General William Barr appointed Bua on November 7, 1991.
    • His report concluded there was "no credible evidence of any criminal wrongdoing" by any past or present Department employee (doc e5c44046, p. 2).
    • INSLAW's rebuttal criticized the special counsel for not interviewing certain witnesses (doc e5c44046, p. 110).

October 15–20, 1993: The Justice Department meets the Casolaro family

This is the most personal record in the cabinet.

  • The briefing memo (October 15, 1993): written for the Attorney General by Assistant Associate Attorney General John C. Dwyer (doc e19da0e4, pp. 160–162).
    • Danny Casolaro's brother had asked for the meeting to discuss "the unusual circumstances surrounding the death of his brother ... and its relation to the INSLAW matter."
    • It sets out the evidence pointing to suicide.
    • It also sets out the aspects that "have created significant doubt in the minds of many":
      • no INSLAW documents were found in the room;
      • Casolaro had told friends he was close to "breaking" the case and feared for his safety;
      • the body was embalmed before the family was notified;
      • the room may not have been sealed, a point the memo marks as "disputed."
  • The memo to the INSLAW file (October 20, 1993): records the meeting itself (doc e19da0e4, pp. 173–174).
    • It was held on Monday, October 18, 1993, with Associate Attorney General Webb Hubbell.
    • The family listed its concerns: a two-day delay in notification, embalming before an autopsy, a room that was not sealed, missing papers, and leads that were not followed up.
    • A family friend said that when Casolaro told her he had "broke" INSLAW, she believed he meant he had found there was "no real conspiracy." The family worried he had uncovered something else.
    • The family asked for two things: help recovering his personal belongings from the police, and a review of the local investigation.

1994 (undated in this copy): The Justice Department's final review

  • Record: the Department's review of the Bua report (doc e5c44046). The pages read carry no date. The year is inferred from the text, which says the dispute "continued for over 12 years" since 1982.
  • What it states:
    • "Based on that review and investigation, we conclude that Mr. Casolaro committed suicide" (p. 110).
    • There is "no credible evidence linking any Justice Department official or any individual other than Mr. Casolaro himself to his death" (p. 9).
    • It recommends against appointing an independent prosecutor (p. 9).
    • A separate Justice Department report devoted to Casolaro's death reaches the same conclusion (doc 8035d8ae, pp. 47–48).

What is established, and what is still disputed

Established by the records:

  • The contract.
  • The 1987 bankruptcy ruling and its later dismissal on jurisdiction.
  • Casolaro's death in room 517 on August 10, 1991.
  • Each official body's stated conclusion.

Disputed:

  • Whether the Department acted in bad faith toward INSLAW. The courts and Congress criticized it, and its own reviews rejected the charges.
  • Whether Casolaro's death was a suicide. Every official investigation in these records concluded it was. His family, INSLAW and others pointed to unanswered questions that the Department's own October 1993 memo lists.

The records here do not settle either question. They show who concluded what, and when.

A citation lets you check what the record says; it does not establish that its claims are true. Sources are U.S. government records released to the public, including releases through the National Archives. Redactions in the originals are kept as they are. Quotations are short and cited, so readers can check each one against the full page.

Records cited

Short IDs above are the first eight characters of each document ID. Page numbers are pages of the document as stored in The Octopus Files, not the numbers printed on the page.

e5c44046INSLAW Report (Justice Department review, NARA DocId 70098624)
e5c44046f9435a04aa60f5d2d84c01b58b32ae08f0176e5b8e75869ca80000c8
eee05fceStaff Study of Allegations Pertaining to the Department of Justice's Handling of a Contract with Inslaw
eee05fce1f81216c731569488591434b66c1e6ff4afbda9d0daa3d7a9132167d
fab664c4Inslaw Affair Investigative Report (House Judiciary Committee)
fab664c493fcda60108fd35e63c63b51df0a0c68605aedf627943434da9f05d0
62a130c5Casolaro Death Press Releases (NARA DocId 70098642)
62a130c5970f4a30ba7808d8964b35338f68956305c1d63ac61d05afab1afec7
e19da0e4INSLAW - Casolaro (NARA DocId 70002067)
e19da0e4c0d85cdba26f99afa56d15a4286ec723d29d8b4d128723952a5407d7
8035d8aeDOJ Report On Daniel J. Casolaro (NARA DocId 70098622)
8035d8ae685a46e9a2ae9289c8f2aca54dbeb69bd948660b36578cb40fac9fea
7f7a3630Inslaw/PROMIS Bua Report
7f7a36300024855855554c7c655d488c9ef3403c5b7d60b3446341749603a33d

Published November 5, 2026.